Would you like to know if disability insurance premiums are subject to FICA? When working toward financial security, especially regarding disability, it is important to know details regarding disability insurance.
An argument often made is whether or not disability insurance premiums are taxable under FICA taxes.
Fortunately, this article explores this reality and digs deeper into how disability insurance premiums and FICA work while also providing precise information to orient and guide you on this relevant financial planning field.
ALSO READ – What Disability Insurance Is Tax Deductible?
What Is FICA?
FICA is the short form of the Federal Insurance Contribution Act and is a federal payroll tax in the United States.
It supports Social Security and Medicare, two essential programs that offer benefits for retirees, people with disabilities, and children of deceased workers. The FICA tax is split into two parts:
Social Security Tax: This tax finances the Social Security program, encompassing retirement, disability, and survivor benefits.
As of the time of writing this article, the Social Security tax rate stands at 6.2% for employers and employees but only applies up to the wage base limit.
Medicare Tax: This tax provides Medicare, an insurance program for people over 65 and those with disabilities. The Medicare tax rate is 1.45% for employers and employees with no wage base limit.
On the Other Hand, Disability insurance refers to an insurance product that pays monthly benefits to its policyholder if they cannot work because of a disability. There are two main types of disability insurance:
Short-term Disability Insurance: This provides a portion of your income for three to six months from when you get disabled.
Long-term Disability Insurance: This provides you with a part of your income for a more extended period, which can be up to when you retire, depending on the policy.
Are Disability Insurance Premiums Subject To FICA?
The tax treatment of disability insurance premiums varies depending on the party that pays for the premiums and the nature of the benefits offered. Here are the scenarios to consider:
1. Employer-Paid Premiums
If your employer were paying the premium for the disability insurance, FICA taxes would not apply to the premium.
However, benefits that would accrue to you from such policies are taxable, and if they are considered wages, they would be subject to FICA.
What this means, however, is that you may not see FICA deductions on the premiums; the benefit that comes to you could be taxed.
2. Employee-Paid Premiums
However, if you, as an employee, use your after-tax dollars to pay for your disability insurance, then the premiums are excluded from FICA taxes.
More importantly, any money received under the policy is usually not taxed or subject to FICA.
3. Shared Premiums
As for the situations where the employer and the employee split the costs for the disability insurance, they can be quite diverse regarding taxation.
The part of the premium the employer pays is usually exempt from FICA, and the part paid from the employee’s post-tax income is also free from FICA.
Whatever is received from such policies may be only partly tax-free, based on the percentage of the premium cost borne by the employer.
ALSO READ – Who Does Disability Insurance Cover?
How Does Tax Treatment Affect Disability Benefits?
It is important to understand the taxation of disability insurance premiums because it determines the net benefits in the event of a disability. Here is how:
Employer-Paid Premiums
Because the premiums are not taxable under FICA, it may seem advantageous at first glance.
However, if you are getting disability benefits, they are mostly subject to taxes, which cuts your income further down.
For instance, if you have a monthly disability benefit of $3000, the taxable portion will lower your net income once the federal tax has been calculated and possibly the state tax, too.
Employee-Paid Premiums
Thus, there is no immediate tax advantage since people pay the premiums using money that has already had taxes deducted.
However, the major advantage is that any disability benefits you are entitled to are not taxable. This could lead to a higher net gain if you get disabled than if you received taxable benefits.
Are Disability Insurance Benefits Subject To FICA?
When you receive disability benefits, the FICA tax treatment depends on the nature of the benefits and how the premiums were paid:
Short-term Disability Benefits: If the benefits are paid under a plan where the employer pays the premiums and they are considered wages, they may be taxed on FICA.
However, the benefits are generally not taxable under the Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) if the employee paid the premiums.
Long-term Disability Benefits: These benefits are usually not considered FICA if received after the last day of work or six calendar months after the previous month the employee worked in the year.
ALSO READ – Disability Insurance vs Workers Compensation
Are NY DBL Benefits Taxable?
New York State DBL is a law that entitles employees who cannot work due to a non-work-related illness or injury to receive cash benefits.
The recipients need to be aware of the taxes involved in these benefits when planning their financial needs during the state of disability.
Taxability Of NY DBL Benefits
The tax treatment of NY DBL benefits depends on whether the employer or the employee paid the premiums for the disability insurance policy. Here are the key points to consider:
Employee-Paid Premiums: For instance, when an employee uses post-tax dollars to pay the premiums for the NY DBL policy, the benefits received are typically not considered taxable income.
Since the premiums were made out of taxed income, the benefits are therefore received tax-exempt, hence providing an element of financial security without necessarily incurring further taxes.
Employer-Paid Premiums: If the employer contributes the premiums for the NY DBL policy, the benefits provided to the employee are generally subject to federal income tax.
The reasoning is that the premiums were not paid out of the employee’s post-tax income; hence, such premiums’ fruits are considered taxable income.
Shared Premiums: However, when the cost of the premiums is split between the employer and the employee, the taxability of the benefits is split proportionately.
The amount of the benefits funded by the employer’s premium is considered taxable, while that supported by the employee’s premium is not taxable.
NY DBL benefits may be taxable or tax-free based on the premiums’ tax treatment.
It is important to note the above difference, which will enable the employees to properly plan for taxes depending on the circumstances when the disability occurs.
It is advisable to seek help from a tax professional, especially if one needs specific advice on tax laws.
Who Pays NY DBL Premium?
New York State Disability Benefits Law or DBL regulation requires employers to offer disability benefits for employees who cannot go to work because of sickness or injury that is not work-related.
The employers and the employees can bear the cost of this insurance depending on certain conditions and terms.
Employer Responsibility
According to NY DBL, employers are mandated to offer disability benefits, and they are usually under the obligation to pay the premiums.
Employers may sponsor their plan or buy one from an insurance company, depending on the circumstances.
This insurance is costly, and it is incurred as one of the overhead costs by the employer to support employees when they are disabled.
Employee Contribution
Employers are normally responsible for most of the premium costs, but the law allows them to pass some of the costs to the employees.
It is legal for employers to deduct up to 0.5% of an employee’s wages, but not exceeding $0.60 per week, to cover the cost of the disability insurance premiums.
This contribution from employees assists in partially catering for the expenses incurred by the employer while at the same time providing reasonable disability benefits to the employees.
In conclusion, NY DBL premiums are paid mostly by the employer. However, the contribution from the employees is limited.
This mutual approach also contributes to the sustainability of the disability benefits program so that employees get the necessary assistance during their disability.
ALSO READ – Benefits Of Long-Term Care Insurance
Who Is Exempt from NYS DBL?
It is established that the NY State Disability Benefits Law Mandates most employers to provide disability benefits to their employees who cannot work for non-work-related illnesses or injuries.
However, some specific categories of employees are not covered by the NYS DBL.
Familiarity with these exemptions is vital for the employer and employees because it helps to identify legal requirements and coverage entitlement.
Exempt Employees
Government Employees: Some workers who do not qualify for NYS DBL are employees of federal, state, and municipal governments, public school teachers, and other administrative staff.
Some of these employees may have their own disability benefits plan offered by their governing bodies.
Religious and Nonprofit Organizations: Ministers, members of religious orders, or employees of certain nonprofit organizations may not be covered by NYS DBL.
These organizations appear to have their mechanisms for addressing the issue of disability benefits for employees.
Independent Contractors and Freelancers: Those working under independent contractors or freelancers are not employees under NYS DBL and, hence, not eligible for its benefits.
These workers must obtain disability insurance to cover them during their working years.
Corporate Officers and Executives: Sometimes, corporate officers and executives may be excluded from NYS DBL if they are the company’s major shareholders and have declined coverage.
The terms for claiming this exclusion differ and should be accompanied by proper documentation and compliance with state laws.
Minor Workers: Other employees that can also be exempted include those in casual employment or for a limited period in a company, such as babysitters or other employees who work for a short time in a particular company, especially those in household employment, under 18 years of age.
In general, NYS DBL offers important financial assistance to many employees during the period of disability; however, there are certain exceptions to this plan.
New York State DBL excludes government employees, members of religious orders, specific nonprofit employees, independent contractors, specific corporate officers, and minor workers.
It is only through understanding these exemptions that you can follow the law to the letter and make good decisions when it comes to disability insurance.
What Is The Difference Between NYS PFL And DBL?
New York State offers two programs to support employees during times of need: the Paid Family Leave (PFL) and Disability Benefits Law (DBL).
Although both give out money in one form or another, they are quite distinct in their aims and criteria.
Purpose And Coverage
NYS PFL: Paid Family Leave allows workers to take time off from work while being protected by their jobs to care for a new child, a sick family member, or if one’s family member has been activated for military service.
PFL guarantees that employees can handle important family commitments without the threat of being fired or losing their paychecks.
NYS DBL: Disability Benefits Law provides cash benefits to employees when they cannot work because of sickness or disability unrelated to their jobs.
DBL mostly deals with extending monetary benefits to employees during personal illnesses, except those arising from workplace accidents or diseases covered under workers’ compensation.
Eligibility and Benefits
Eligibility: PFL is accessible to employees who have been with their employer for at least 26 weeks in a row if they work full-time or 175 days if they work part-time. On the other hand, DBL may be provided to an employee after four successive working weeks have been completed.
Benefits: PFL benefits are comparatively more elaborate, where PFL provides up to 67 percent of an employee’s average weekly wage up to the percentage of the state’s average weekly wage.
DBL benefits are lower, costing up to 50 percent of the average weekly wage with a maximum of $170 per week.
NYS PFL and DBL both play vital roles in supporting employees, but they cater to different needs: PFL is aimed primarily at family matters, while DBL is designed for personal sickness or illness.
Knowledge of the differences between these programs allows the employees to make the right choices regarding their leaves.
ALSO READ – Disability Insurance As Passive Income
Final Thought
Now that we have established that disability insurance premiums are subject to FICA, it is important to note that disability insurance and its taxation features, such as FICA, can be bewildering to manage.
In summary, it is important to note that while it is exempt from FICA for employer-paid premiums for disability insurance, the benefits received can be taxable and may be subject to FICA.
On the other hand, the premiums paid by the employees using their post-tax income result in tax-exempt benefits.
Recognizing these differences will assist you in making proper decisions regarding your disability insurance and overall financial management.
However, for specific advice concerning your situation, it is recommended to seek assistance from a tax consultant or a financial planner.
They can give advice depending on your situation and also assist in making certain that you make the best out of the disability insurance while avoiding unnecessary taxes.